Response reports to another expert

When the other party has already filed an expert report, a response report addresses each of their items in turn. We inspect the same work, test the reasoning and citations, and give an independent opinion on every item.

Who it's for

  • Builders responding to an owner's expert
  • Owners responding to a builder's expert
  • Lawyers preparing for a compulsory conference or conclave

What's assessed

  • Each item in the opposing report, inspected on site
  • Whether the cited standard actually applies and says what's claimed
  • Measurements, tolerances and photographs relied on
  • Proposed repair scopes and whether they're proportionate

What you receive

  • A response to every item, cross-referenced to the original
  • Clear agree, partly agree or disagree position with reasons
  • Alternative repair methods where the proposed scope goes too far
  • Material ready for a joint expert report or Scott schedule

Typical process

  1. Enquiry and conflict check. We confirm we haven't acted for another party in the matter.
  2. Initial matter review. We review your documents and photos and identify the issues.
  3. Scope and fee proposal. Written scope, fixed fee and delivery date before work begins.
  4. Inspection and report. Site inspection, then the report delivered by the agreed date.
Worth knowing

Disagreeing for the sake of it costs credibility. Where the other expert is right, the response says so.

Request an assessment